On the 26th of November, 2008, Mumbai was attacked. It was bombed in several locations, including the Taj Mahal Hotel, The Oberoi Hotel, and the railway station. Soon we'll know whether it's peace or not.
On the 26th of December, 2008, my grandmother will return home from the hospital. She was getting a tumor removed from her intestine. Soon we'll know whether it's cancer or not.
I can't really tell which one means more to me. So today, to make up for missing yesterday, I'm putting up two pieces. One is my own personal reflection on Mumbai. The second is something I wrote about a place called Kanya Kumari. Funny as this may sound, my grandmother's name is Kanya Kumari- the tip of India. Let's start with the one about my grandmother. How are they related? Well, I guess you'll just have to read ahead to know that.
Kanya Kumari: The Tip of India
Boats line the coastline of Kanya Kumari
The tip of India
The beauty of a country varies. Its people are serene and its land is unspoiled. It is beautiful. Its people are scared and smoldering with anger. Its land is incredible but exploited. It is beautiful. Somehow, even the touching view of the boats lined across the very tip of India is a melancholic site, that leaves a long-lasting impression. The vast sea is their office, a dilapidated canoe their desk. From the sandy shores, they can distinctly see, three waters abruptly coinciding- the vivid turqoise of the Indian Ocean, the yellow-green of the Bay of Bengal, and the deep, distant blue view of the Arabian Sea.
The Pakistanis hate the Indians. The Indians hate Arabs. Muslims hate Hindus. Hindus hate Muslims. The amount of hate in the beautiful nation of India is huge. As I stood on the very tip of India, I noticed something profound; that very point was where the Indian Ocean, the Arabian Sea, and the Bay of Bengal met. I found it quite odd that we fight against each other, though it is unnatural. We label water, sky, and land as ours simply to fulfill our sad human need for an identity and power.
A Global World, A Global Terror
A normal view in Mumbai, before the attacks
My friend's grandparents sitting in their home in Mumbai a few years ago
My morning began just as it always does. I woke up to the blaring of a radio jockey, who spoke in Hindi that was too quick and complicated for me to comprehend at 6:45 in the morning.
After turning off my alarm, I stumbled back into my warm, comforting blankets, as usual. At 7 o’ clock, my mother entered my room to drag me out of bed, at which point I gave her a drowsy lecture on how children aren’t fit for such rigid schedules, as usual. I cursed society, and begged the Gods to magically cancel school and let me go back to sleep, as usual.
Then my mother said something, “a joke” I thought. “You should get out of bed, and put life in context. Last night Mumbai was attacked. The Oberoi and the Taj were bombed. Militants are roaming the streets, and shooting anyone that they wish to. That could have been you or me. Those are places we’ve stayed in. Those are streets you’ve walked on.”
She left the room, having woken me up quicker than ever before. I sat in bed, shaken by déjà vu.
On September 11, 2001, the exact same thing had happened. I woke up to talking and screaming on the radio that I couldn’t understand. The confusion was explained to me, the little second grader in the house, just as it would be explained seven years later, to the not-so-little sophomore.
I don’t see much of a difference in the events of September 11th, 2001, and November 26th, 2008. Terrorists rammed a plane into two buildings in America’s financial capital, and one in its political capital. Terrorists bombed lots of buildings in India’s financial capital. America. India. No difference.
At school we sang the national anthem, and observed a moment of silence. Every person I greeted in the halls said something like “Did you hear what happened?” or “I can’t believe the news.” Is this Bangalore in the present, or San Jose in the past?
Seven years ago, I lived in Saratoga, California. Now, I live in Bangalore, India. Terror strikes everywhere.
We live in a world where terrorists based in Afghanistan can kill nearly 3000 Americans that are almost 11,000 miles away- one time. Pakistan and India, two neighboring nations that were once united as a single country, harass and torment each other- perpetually.
I felt confused, and disconcerted when 9/11 happened. Now, I am crushed, yet optimistic.
Today’s teenagers, my generation, are the lucky inheritors of a “free” country, a global world, technology, planes, rockets, missiles, and panic. We will scramble for the environment. We will break through the barriers of medicine. We will strive to eradicate poverty. We will fight for human rights. Why?
Is it to sustain an inhumane humanity? Keeping our race alive and thriving isn’t bad. It is the murdering of innocent individuals that is.
We do not place enough, nor the right kind of importance on solving terrorism. Responding with more violence and destruction is not the best way to stop it.
Our goal is to “fight terrorism.” The word “fight” is taken too literally. By going to war, America has gained a lot of hatred around the world.
Am I justifying terrorism? Hardly. But as far as I can tell, tomorrow’s leaders will need a lot more than an exploding wallet, more nuclear weapons, and empty words.
War has rarely solved problems in the past. It builds peace as strong as a house of cards.
World War II was arguably caused by the tension built up after harsh punishment was enforced on the losing side in World War I. Pakistan and India have been childishly arguing since their independence. The Middle East and America seem to have started their petty play as well.
The problem is that every group ardently believes in their own ideas and ideals as dogma. Every person also makes an effort, big or small, to be identified with a particular group, creating factions of intolerance. People are proud to have a large social crowd with which they belong. That could be as broad as being American, or as narrow as being a member of your own little best friends trio. These small divisions create large conflicts.
It is imperative that society realizes that we live in a global world, not one of provincial labeling. I am an American of Indian ethnicity, currently living in India. The neighborhood I live in has all kinds of nationalities from British, Japanese, and Tanzanians, to Peruvians, Canadians, and Australians. On my way to school, I might talk to my French friend about our Modern European history class or what the best fruits to eat with Nutella are. I pass by mosques, temples, and churches. In school, I discuss terrorism with people whose accents constantly test my ability to understand English. Then in Spanish class, I read an article about the Mumbai attacks from the newspaper El País. I watch Hindi movies with English subtitles on the weekends. I read about western popular culture in The Times of India, the national newspaper. This isn’t just my story. This is everyone’s story.
Globalization has made a world of 195 distinctively separate nations, a large mass of thousands of varying views belonging to its inhabitants. Terrorism, and fighting exists when people try to bundle others in a package. Instead of viewing each person individually, we subconsciously stereotype by religion, race, nationality, and gender.
The causes and the cases of terrorism are infinite. The cures, on the other hand, are numbered.
They are mostly what people call “too” idealistic. Suggestions like, we can have peaceful, open-minded discussion, or we can all disarm, are openly applauded, and yet they never happen. Maybe I’m too young. Maybe I’m too naïve, but I have hope that a time will come when idealism will become realism.
To me, we are already more than just Americans and Afghanis, Indians and Pakistanis, or pacifists and warmongers. We are global citizens.
By Tara Kola, not only a fifteen year old, or a Bharatanatyam dancer, or an American, but a global citizen.
Showing posts with label Mumbai. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Mumbai. Show all posts
Sunday, December 21, 2008
We are paintings of the past
Posted by tk at 9:04 AM 0 comments
Labels: History, India, Kanya Kumari, Mumbai
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)